Impact of incentivizing supervisor-led monitoring and assistance to improve glasses wear adherence among the Indian garment factory workers: A clustered randomized controlled trial

Last registered on March 21, 2023

Pre-Trial

Trial Information

General Information

Title
Impact of incentivizing supervisor-led monitoring and assistance to improve glasses wear adherence among the Indian garment factory workers: A clustered randomized controlled trial
RCT ID
AEARCTR-0009752
Initial registration date
August 23, 2022

Initial registration date is when the trial was registered.

It corresponds to when the registration was submitted to the Registry to be reviewed for publication.

First published
August 25, 2022, 2:00 PM EDT

First published corresponds to when the trial was first made public on the Registry after being reviewed.

Last updated
March 21, 2023, 8:51 AM EDT

Last updated is the most recent time when changes to the trial's registration were published.

Locations

Region

Primary Investigator

Affiliation
University of Michigan

Other Primary Investigator(s)

PI Affiliation
University of Michigan
PI Affiliation
Queen's University Belfast

Additional Trial Information

Status
In development
Start date
2023-02-15
End date
2023-05-15
Secondary IDs
Prior work
This trial does not extend or rely on any prior RCTs.
Abstract
In 2013, the World Health Organization (WHO) set eye health as a priority by creating the “Universal Eye Health: A Global Action Plan 2014-2019.” The WHO’s reasoning is intuitive; poor visual health can impair quality of life in a number of ways- by limiting physical activity, causing emotional health problems, damaging work performance. In India, 55 million people suffer from presbyopia (the degeneration of sight related to age). Apart from the large-scale negative impact on quality of life, untreated visual impairments including presbyopia, are estimated to cost the Indian economy $37 billion in productivity losses annually.

This study is an extension of a previous trial, which aimed to measure adherence to eye glasses and willingness to pay of the presbyopic sewing operators with glasses either free of cost or upon the payment of a nominal amount and consequently complying to regular wear of glasses for personal and firm’s benefits. We found out that providing glasses for free or at a nominal cost did not equate to adherence to glasses wear as we found less than 2% of the workers wearing glasses at the endline survey . We then conducted a short one month non-randomized pilot on 253 workers, where we introduced an element of incentivising monitoring and encouragement of glasses wear through supervsiors to improve adherence rates where we found that adherence to glasses wear among the workers increased to 47% in the first two weeks and further increased to 77% by the end the pilot (after four weeks).

To further explore the validity and scalability of the incentive based monitoring through supervisors for glasses wear adherence encouragement, we now propose conducting a clustered randomised controlled trial on a sample of the same 229 workers, where we randomly assign 25 (out of 50) supervisors to receive incentives based on tasks related to monitoring, assisting and encouraging workers with presbyopia to wear and get accustomed to the glasses. Each supervisor will be responsible for a group of 4-6 workers. The trial takes the form of a clustered randomised controlled trial with randomisation at the supervisor level (clusters).

We hypothesize that providing supervisor-led monitoring and assistance to glasses wear to workers with presbyopia will improve the usability and adherence to eyeglasses, increase their perceived and actual productivity, and ultimately contribute to their wellbeing.



External Link(s)

Registration Citation

Citation
Adhvaryu, Achyuta, Nathan Congdon and Anant Nyshadham. 2023. "Impact of incentivizing supervisor-led monitoring and assistance to improve glasses wear adherence among the Indian garment factory workers: A clustered randomized controlled trial." AEA RCT Registry. March 21. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9752-2.0
Sponsors & Partners

There is information in this trial unavailable to the public. Use the button below to request access.

Request Information
Experimental Details

Interventions

Intervention(s)
The supervisors will be offered training to provide assistance, encouragement and monitoring the glasses wear adherence in the allotted worker groups of 4-6 workers on a total sample of 229 workers. The treatment assignment is clustered at supervisor level and 25 (out of 50) supervisors will be eligible for a two level progressive incentive scheme based on the proportionate percentage of workers in their group who continue wearing glasses at times of surreptitious observation.
Intervention (Hidden)
Explore the effectiveness of incentives to supervisors/captains in sustaining adherence to glasses wear among the workers. We aim to conduct a clustered RCT for one month wherein a sample of 229 workers, who are presbyopic and have been offered glasses free of cost, will be divided into groups of 4-7 workers and allotted a supervisor/captain(clusters). As the supervisors will be requested to take up an additional responsibility of ensuring adherence to glasses wear in their groups, the supervisors in the treatment group will be eligible for two rounds of incentives, the first incentive will be offered after 2 weeks of observation and the second, at the end of the study. Furthermore, the supervisors will also have the option to receive a better quality incentive proportionate to the rate of adherence observed in their assigned batch of workers.
We will explore the variation in glasses wear compliance by randomising eligibility to incentives to only 50% of the supervisors/captains for the scalability purpose of the research design. Out of the 50 captains in the implementation factory, we will randomly select 25 supervisors who will continue to be incentivised for one month and 25 who won’t be receiving any incentives.

Intervention Start Date
2023-03-30
Intervention End Date
2023-04-30

Primary Outcomes

Primary Outcomes (end points)
Adherence to glasses wear
Primary Outcomes (explanation)
The proposed study is a part of a larger trial, PROSPER 3 (Trial registered online at ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT04654013). As a learning from one of our previous studies, which aimed to measure adherence to eye glasses and willingness to pay of the presbyopic sewing operators with glasses either free of cost or upon the payment of a nominal amount and consequently complying to regular wear of glasses for personal and firm’s benefits, we found out that providing glasses for free or at a nominal cost does not equate to adherence to glasses wear as less than 2% of the workers were found to be wearing glasses at the time of endline survey. Among other reasons, which have been addressed in the PROSPER 3 design, a key element that struck as a major shortcoming of the previous study was removal of the treatment arms comprising glasses wear assistance due to the third wave of Corona virus in India. This treatment arm aimed to address the glasses wear problems faced by the study participants and observe adherence through monitoring assistance from worker’s supervisors and captains. To cater to this shortfall, we conducted a month long pilot introducing incentivised monitoring and encouragement of glasses wear through supervisors among the presbyopic workers where we found that adherence increased to 47% in the first two weeks and further increased to 77% in the weeks following the distribution of the first gift to captains.

As the pilot was a non-RCT study, we now propose a clustered randomzied controlled trial focussing on measuring the adherence to glasses wear as the key outcome variable wherein we introduce a randomization to eligibility to the incentives to half of the supervisors (25 of the 50 supervisors) to explore whether the adherence to glasses wear rates are sustained through ways of habit formation for purposes of scalability of this proposed design.

Secondary Outcomes

Secondary Outcomes (end points)
self-reported well-being, self reported productivity, attitudes towards glasses
Secondary Outcomes (explanation)
The study team would also explore other worker level outcomes that could be affected with glasses wear adherence such as self-reported wellbeing, perceived productivity and attitudes towards glasses wear. We would also explore the change in actual productivity measurements through factory collected individual and line level data.

Experimental Design

Experimental Design
We will provide training to all the supervisors on providing tools of monitoring, assistance and encouragement to ensure adherence of glasses wear among the workers that will be alloted to each supervsior.

We will then test the glasses wear adherence rates among the workers with supervisor-level randomization of the incentives. We will be doing a randomisation to assign 25 supervisors (out of 50) to be eligible for the treatment.
Treatment arm: Supervisors eligible for incentive scheme, along with training.
Control arm: Supervisors will only be provided with training.

The data collection will be divided in three rounds, namely:
1) Through Round 1 data collection (at the beginning of the trial) we would be able to capture the baseline adherence to glasses wear among the workers in the sample.
2) Through Round 2 data collection (after 2 weeks of introducing monitoring and assistance from supervsiors), we would explore the impact of introducing selective incentivization of supervision and assistance from supervisors/captains on adherence rates of glasses wear among the workers.
3) Through Round 3 data collection (end of the trial) , we would explore the persistence of the effects of selective incentives to supervisors/captains on worker glasses wear adherence and evidence for habit formation trends towards glasses wear. We will also be collecting worker level outcomes that could be affected with glasses wear adherence such as self-reported wellbeing, perceived productivity and attitudes towards glasses wear. We would also explore the change in actual productivity measurements through factory collected individual and line level data.
Experimental Design Details
We will initially collect the first round of observations in the factory, on a sample of 229 workers, where the enumerators will surreptitiously collect observation data on the adherence to glasses wear in the factory. This will be done to capture the glasses wear self motivated habit formation trends from the workers, despite no supervision and monitoring from their captains and supervisors.

We will then create worker supervisor groups of 4-6 workers, based on the supervisor/captain's physical vicinity to their group participants and ease of supervision without hampering their daily production targets. As the supervisors/captains will be requested to take up an additional responsibility of ensuring adherence to glasses wear in their groups. They will be provided with a training to equip them to manage monitoring and provide assistance to their workers. The treatment supervisors/captains will be eligible for two rounds of incentives, the first incentive will be offered after 2 weeks of observation and the second, at the end of the study. Furthermore, the supervisors will have the option to receive a better quality incentive proportionate to the rate of adherence observed in their assigned batch of workers. Out of the 50 captains in the implementation factory, we will randomly select 25 supervisors who will continue to be incentivised for one month and 25 who won’t be receiving any incentives.

We aim to explore the following aspects through this extension:
1) Through Round 1 data collection (at the beginning of the trial) we would be able to capture adherence to glasses wear, with no additional supervision or incentives.
2) Through Round 2 data collection (after 2 weeks of introducing monitoring and assistance), we would explore the impact of introducing selective incentivization of supervision and assistance from supervisors/captains on adherence rates.
3) Through Round 3 data collection (end of the trial) , we would explore the persistence of the effects of selective incentives to supervisors/captains on worker glasses wear adherence and evidence for habit formation trends towards glasses wear. We will also be collecting worker level outcomes that could be affected with glasses wear adherence such as self-reported wellbeing, perceived productivity and attitudes towards glasses wear. We would also explore the change in actual productivity measurements through factory collected individual and line level data.
Randomization Method
Randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization Unit
The randomization unit is clustered at supervisor level
Was the treatment clustered?
Yes

Experiment Characteristics

Sample size: planned number of clusters
50 supervisors
Sample size: planned number of observations
229
Sample size (or number of clusters) by treatment arms
25 supervisors (clusters)
Minimum detectable effect size for main outcomes (accounting for sample design and clustering)
NA
IRB

Institutional Review Boards (IRBs)

IRB Name
Queen's University Belfast
IRB Approval Date
2022-06-14
IRB Approval Number
QUB, MHLS 20_84
IRB Name
Good Business Lab
IRB Approval Date
2022-06-29
IRB Approval Number
NA

Post-Trial

Post Trial Information

Study Withdrawal

There is information in this trial unavailable to the public. Use the button below to request access.

Request Information

Intervention

Is the intervention completed?
No
Data Collection Complete
Data Publication

Data Publication

Is public data available?
No

Program Files

Program Files
Reports, Papers & Other Materials

Relevant Paper(s)

Reports & Other Materials